Following the ruling of the Alabama Supreme Court that states that frozen embryos are considered children, and that a person could be held liable for accidentally destroying them, Elizabeth Carr, the first IVF baby born in the United States 42 years ago has reflected on feeling like an “endangered species.”
Born in 1981 as a result of the pioneering work of Drs. Howard and Georgeanna Jones at the Jones Institute in Norfolk, Virginia, the Elizabeth’s birth marked the advent of in vitro fertilization (IVF) in the country.
Initially developed to address irreparable damage to a woman’s fallopian tubes, IVF has evolved into a primary therapy for various causes of infertility, boasting a high success rate. Elizabeth’s parents, driven by their own struggles with infertility, shared their story with the world to raise awareness about IVF, then considered a groundbreaking procedure.
However, recent events, notably an Alabama Supreme Court ruling treating frozen embryos as “extrauterine children,” have cast a shadow over the IVF landscape. The ruling raises concerns about clinics facing liability for wrongful death claims in case of lab accidents and complicates the storage and disposal of embryos. Several clinics have halted IVF procedures, impacting residents’ access to treatment within the state and hindering the movement of embryos for treatment elsewhere.
Elizabeth contends that the ruling reflects a lack of understanding of the IVF process and a disregard for the science of assisted reproductive technology. While emphasizing that embryos are not children, she underscores that IVF success means bringing home a baby, not just creating embryos—a nuanced and intricate journey involving multiple steps.
IVF, described as a miracle of modern medicine and a manifestation of unwavering hope, has become more challenging for Alabamians due to recent legal developments. Elizabeth advocates for legislative protection of IVF treatments, expressing optimism in the support from Gov. Kay Ivey, who recognizes the importance of fostering a culture of life that includes aiding couples utilizing IVF.
Amid these uncertainties, Elizabeth remains resolute in her belief that science, coupled with compassionate legislation, will pave the way for a future where the dreams of parenthood through IVF are safeguarded, cherished, and celebrated.
Alabama Supreme Court’s Decision on Frozen Embryos Sparks Concerns and Inquiries into Fertility Care
